The Chantilly racecourse in the Oise department is hosting a puppy show this weekend that's causing a stir among animal rights groups. While more than 500 puppies from some thirty professional breeders are trying to attract visitors, two groups, Paz and Argos 42, are denouncing a practice they believe is incompatible with animal ethics.
Shop windows deemed irresponsible by activists
Outside the enclosure, a few activists from the Animal Rights Party are warning families about the risks of impulse buying. According to them, animals are sold as consumer products, often without respecting the legal withdrawal period. A report by Argos 42 published in 2024 estimates that nearly half of the puppies purchased at these fairs end up abandoned. The organizers strongly dispute these figures, as does the idea that these events encourage a form of trafficking or intensive breeding. The municipality of Nogent-sur-Oise, alerted by the same associations in July, recently pledged to no longer host this type of event. Chantilly, on the other hand, is allowing the fair to proceed, pointing out that the event is being held on a private site, owned by the Institut de France, and that no violations have been observed.
Professionals who defend their model
In the face of criticism, breeders insist on their seriousness. With up-to-date vaccinations, veterinary visits after each show, and adoption tracking, exhibitors assure that they take care of their animals. They consider these shows an essential tool for maintaining their business, in a context of declining home sales. With the cost of a purebred puppy often exceeding €1, they believe buyers are fully aware of their commitment. For Kevin Blaison, organizer of the show, the controversy is nothing new. He assures that the shows are registered with the Ministry of Agriculture and points out that many private venues can host these events, even if the city refuses. While opponents regret the lack of response from the city and the Institut de France, the Chantilly town hall claims to have no evidence justifying intervention. The debate remains open: between responsible adoption and the unabashed pet trade, the puppy show model is increasingly divisive.
