Media Television

Amine El-Khatmi forced to leave CNews by Arcom, which tracks his airtime: a double standard, as seen with Ilan Gabet, LFI activist on BFMTV and RMC.

Amine El-Khatmi forced to leave CNews by Arcom, which tracks his airtime: a double standard, as seen with Ilan Gabet, LFI activist on BFMTV and RMC.
Amine El-Khatmi forced to leave CNews by Arcom, which tracks his airtime: a double standard, as seen with Ilan Gabet, LFI activist on BFMTV and RMC.

After 10 years at CNews, Amine El-Khatmi announced his departure, a consequence of Arcom's decision to now count his appearances as right-wing political airtime. This decision sparked controversy surrounding the treatment of Ilan Gabet, a member of La France Insoumise , whose appearances on BFMTV and RMC are not subject to the same counting. These two situations raise an awkward question for the broadcasting regulator: are the same criteria applied to all political commentators?

10 years on CNews, then a decision by Arcom that changed everything

This announcement has sparked strong reactions in the French media landscape. On Sunday, Amine El-Khatmi announced he would no longer be a commentator on CNews, after ten years with the Canal+ group's news channel . The reason: the decision by the Audiovisual and Digital Communication Regulatory Authority (ARDA) to now classify his appearances as those of a right-wing political figure.

On X, the person in question confirmed his departure: "After ten years on CNews , I will no longer be a commentator on the channel, as ARCOM has decided to deduct my speaking time as a 'right-wing political figure'."

This new classification has consequences. Amine El-Khatmi's appearances must now be included in CNews's political airtime records. The channel must therefore take his positions into account while respecting the rules of fairness between the different political currents, which complicates maintaining his regular presence on air.

The former president of the Committee for Secularism and the Republic, known for his pro-secular stance and criticism of Islamism, made no secret of his anger. After thanking Pascal Praud, Laurence Ferrari, Christine Kelly , and several CNews executives, he directly attacked the regulatory body: "In France , everything is falling apart, but civil servants are paid to police public debate. Just another heresy in the land of all heresies."

Amine El-Khatmi also affirmed his willingness to continue his commitments and publicly defend his convictions, despite the end of his regular collaboration with the channel.

Ilan Gabet, a member of La France Insoumise (LFI), considered neutral: the difference in treatment denounced

The controversy takes on a new dimension with the case of Ilan Gabet, who appears on BFMTV and RMC and is presented as an activist for La France Insoumise (LFI). Arcom reportedly informed the two media outlets that his appearances could continue to be considered those of a non-political commentator, without being counted towards LFI's allotted airtime.

The comparison raises a question. Why must the interventions of a columnist identified as right-wing now be counted politically, while those of a speaker presented as a left-wing activist could continue to fall under ordinary journalistic debate?

Ilan Gabet's activism had already prompted a complaint to Arcom

Ilan Gabet's case is not new. As early as May 29, his participation in the Estelle Midi program, on RMC and RMC Story , had provoked a controversy over his presentation as a simple law student.

He was notably criticized for appearing in debates without his political affiliations and support for Jean-Luc Mélenchon being clearly indicated to viewers. A referral to Arcom was then announced, requesting the regulator to examine the conditions under which this speaker was presented.

The issue therefore concerned not only Ilan Gabet's personal opinions, but also the transparency of his political stance. In September, further reports were encouraged after several other appearances on Estelle Midi , always under the guise of a law student.

Five months after the first controversy, the contrast with the treatment reserved for Amine El-Khatmi appears all the more striking: on the one hand, a columnist forced to give up his regular collaboration with CNews after his classification on the right; on the other, a speaker publicly supporting LFI whose speaking time would not be counted politically.

Rules of pluralism that nevertheless apply to all channels

Arcom is responsible for ensuring political pluralism on television and radio. Broadcasters must declare the airtime allotted to political figures and ensure a fair distribution of airtime between different political viewpoints, according to criteria established by the regulator.

Since a 2024 reform, the control of pluralism is no longer limited to elected officials and official party representatives. It also concerns the expression of different currents of thought and opinion through all participants in news programs.

In June 2026, Arcom had in fact formally ordered CNews to respect its pluralism obligations, after examining 168 hours of programming broadcast in March 2025. The regulator had noted a lasting imbalance in the representation of opinions.

But these obligations also apply to BFMTV, RMC, and RMC Story. Respect for pluralism depends neither on a channel's editorial line nor on the political orientation of its contributors.

Why would Amine El-Khatmi be considered political and Ilan Gabet neutral?

This is now the question raised by this affair. Amine El-Khatmi is no longer simply considered a commentator expressing opinions: his contributions are now counted towards the right wing's allotted speaking time. Conversely, Ilan Gabet, despite his support for La France Insoumise, would benefit from a different classification.

Regulations do not automatically require that every party supporter be considered a political figure. Party membership, responsibilities held, and the nature of interventions may be taken into account. However, these criteria must be sufficient to explain the decisions made.

The controversy therefore goes beyond the mere departure of Amine El-Khatmi. It concerns the consistency of the classifications adopted by Arcom and their consequences for news channels.

While awaiting an explanation for the alleged difference in treatment, one fact remains: Amine El-Khatmi has announced the end of his 10-year collaboration with CNews, while Ilan Gabet continues to be the subject of controversy over the presentation of his political commitment on air.

Share this article

Your news, according to your interests

Choose the sections and language of your newsletter. You can change your preferences at any time.

Respond to the article

Be the first to comment on this article.

Respond to this article Cancel

Comments are moderated. Promotional messages, automated emails, and abusive links are blocked.

Your first comment, or any message containing a link, may be placed pending approval.

Interview Application

Information everywhere you go

Find the latest news, alerts and your favorite sections in an experience designed for mobile.

Interview app alerts screen: latest news alerts
Customization screen for Interview app sections
News screen of the Interview app: the featured story
Photo credits (2)