Media Television

VIDEO - “You say I'm fanning the flames? I don't douse my teachers with gasoline!” The huge clash on LCI between Louise (UNI) and Elwan, the pro-Mélenchon high school student

Wednesday evening on LCI, the face-off between Louise, head of the Bordeaux section of UNI, and Elwan, the high school student who became famous for his support of Jean-Luc Mélenchon, led to a heated verbal confrontation. Guest on La Grande Confrontation, in David Pujadas’s show, the young student denounced school blockades, violence during protests, and the behavior of some activists. Facing Elwan, she defended the high school students who want to continue studying and accused the leaders of the protest of sacrificing their schooling. Before telling the young activist: “You are the useful idiots of this movement!”

“I don’t douse my teachers with gasoline!”

From the start of her intervention, Louise responded to the criticisms made against her, notably about her attitude and supposed aggressiveness. “I am far from aggressive, believe me. You say I’m fanning the flames a bit. Meanwhile, I don’t douse my teachers with gasoline.”

The UNI leader was referring to the violence accompanying the high school blockades, notably in La Ciotat, where a principal was doused with gasoline and assaulted. On October 2, the Ministry of National Education reported 564 disrupted schools and 65 staff members injured since the start of the movement, including 40 principals.

Louise then accused her interlocutor of trying to excuse some violent behaviors by invoking the personal situations of their perpetrators. “You absolve those who do it by saying: ‘But we don’t know what happened, what they went through?’ Nothing justifies dousing a teacher with gasoline. That’s clear and straightforward.”

“You are an extremely noisy minority!”

The student continued by challenging the representativeness of the mobilized high school students. According to her, activists in favor of blockades impose their decisions on a silent majority who would like to attend classes normally: “You call me selfish. But in fact, you are an extremely noisy minority. There are many more high school students who simply want to study and don’t want to be blocked, yet they carry your demands.”

Louise also denounced the methods used to prevent access to schools. “You feel so powerful that you even forget that blocking entire schools is illegal. You are in total illegality.” A categorical statement, while the legality of a blockade depends notably on its methods, obstruction to class access, and acts committed.

She then defended a conception of school based on work and individual success: “We defend those who want to work, those who still believe in the value of effort, merit, and excellence, which you are tearing away from them.”

Louise turns Elwan’s discourse on the suburbs against him

Another notable moment of this confrontation: the question of remote classes, sometimes presented as a solution for students prevented from accessing their high school. Louise reproached Elwan for defending youth from working-class neighborhoods while supporting methods that, according to her, risk penalizing the most disadvantaged students: “You who still speak for the suburbs, how do they follow remote classes in the suburbs when they have tiny apartments, with little brothers and sisters making noise nearby, and no computer?”

She continued by directly challenging the political convictions defended by her interlocutor: “The humanist left, the left that advocates equality, is false. And you embody it perfectly.”

This criticism notably targets the gap she denounces between speeches in favor of equal opportunity and the practical consequences of blockades on students whose families lack favorable conditions for schoolwork at home.

“Your little suit, your little well-prepared phrases…”

Louise then personally attacked Elwan, whose notoriety has significantly increased since the broadcast of his first interventions in high school protests.

The young man was notably filmed on Tuesday, October 6, kissing Jean-Luc Mélenchon, before stating that the insubordinate leader was the one who would save France.

On LCI, Louise reproached him for his attitude, smile, and way of expressing himself during the debate: “With your little suit, your little well-prepared phrases, you have incredible eloquence. And I think many are very proud of you. I understand them, but you have such a mocking smile. It’s crazy to be like that.”

Despite interruptions, she insisted on continuing her reasoning: “There are thousands of high school students who don’t want their place of study blocked. And you, you look at them with a big smile and tell them: ‘Well, it’s not serious, it’s in support of…’”

“You are the useful idiots of this movement!”

The most offensive part of her intervention came when she accused Elwan and other media figures of the mobilization of diverting attention from the initial demands: “Let those who really need to protest, protest. Give them the floor. You are taking everything over.” Louise then warned she would toughen her tone: “Sorry to tell you this, and I may seem a bit aggressive, but it’s much needed: you are the useful idiots of this movement.”

An attack against the young activist, whom she accuses of serving, according to her, the interests of other political actors while contributing to discrediting the high school protest: “No one talks about your demands anymore. Everyone talks about the chaos you are causing everywhere in the streets. It’s that simple. You are used, you are instrumentalized, and don’t tell me otherwise.”

“The high school students who had real demands are no longer heard, because of you”

To conclude, Louise stressed the consequences of violence and blockades on the image of the movement. While incidents multiply around schools, she considers that students with legitimate demands have lost the chance to be heard: “In any case, I am sincerely sorry for the high school students who had real demands in the suburbs, because today, they are no longer heard at all, because of you.”

This new televised confrontation comes after a first very tense exchange on LCI between Louise and another high school student, who complained about his schedule in front of the UNI leader. The day before, Elwan had sparked another controversy after a remark addressed to a Black woman, who replied: “Because I’m Black?”

In a few days, Louise and Elwan have become two opposing faces of the debate on the high school mobilization. One defends the freedom to study, authority, and merit; the other supports a political and social protest that now goes beyond schools. Wednesday evening, in front of LCI cameras, Louise made her opposition to blockades a particularly harsh attack against the pro-Mélenchon high school student.

Share this article

Your news, according to your interests

Choose the sections and language of your newsletter. You can change your preferences at any time.

Interview Application

Information everywhere you go

Find the latest news, alerts and your favorite sections in an experience designed for mobile.

Interview app alerts screen: latest news alerts
Customization screen for Interview app sections
News screen of the Interview app: the featured story